› Forums › 2004 FOT48 Information Archive › 2004 Planning Meeting › Confirmation E-mail issues

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Stephen
    Participant
      June 28, 2004 at 1:51 pm
      Post count: 759
      #46857 |

      Found a flaw with the automatic registrations.

      It appears that e-mails from the registration script to some service providers are not being delivered. In a nutshell it’s due to reverse domain lookups being performed on the sender.

      Since we send the message through a virtual server hosted remotely (sitelutions.com) that is the IP address that is appearing on the e-mail. Doing a lookup on that IP address returns sitelutions.com, which is obviously different than the from address of flagsonthe48.org, thus the message is dropped as a relayed spam message.

      I am in contact with our webhost to see if this can be worked around. So far, this appears to affect Comcast and SBC, but could affect others. Essentially, any ISP performs a reverse-DNS lookup on messages as a spam tool would fail these messages. Some would be nice and put them in a junk folder. Others (like Comcast and SBC apparently) just drop them straight out, with no bounce message sent.

      -Stephen

      SilentCal
      Moderator
        June 28, 2004 at 7:22 pm
        Post count: 1307
        #49572

        In a word :blink: thank god you guys know what your doing!

        Stephen
        Participant
          June 29, 2004 at 2:32 pm
          Post count: 759
          #49573

          I found it! Comcast has a spam e-mail filter option.

          1) Do you want us to filter spam?
          2) Do you want it put into a folder or deleted?

          If you answer yes- deleted, any message that fails a reverse DNS lookup will never arrive.

          About 45-50% of domains would fail this lookup. Anything hosted on a virtual server.

          Best way around this- put a message on the registration that “confirmation e-mails may be filtered out by certain spam filters (such as Comcast or SBC). Please check your spam folder as this could be the case if your confirmation does not arrive.”

          -Stephen

          rbhayes
            June 30, 2004 at 12:30 am
            Post count: 69
            #49574

            We’re going to be away this weekend and will have limited Internet access through dialup. We would like to sign up for a peak again this year – what time do you expect the sign up process to be open?

            MtnMagic
              June 30, 2004 at 10:55 pm
              Post count: 372
              #49575

              Bob,
              You may sign up today. Officially it begins 7/4.

              _______________
              2001-2004 Cabot

            • Author
              Posts
            Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
            • The topic ‘Confirmation E-mail issues’ is closed to new replies.